The Doble SFRA Resource Center

Welcome to the Doble SFRA Resource Center.

FRA is the general term for Frequency Response Analysis; SFRA is specific to Sweep measurements which are more repeatable and reliable for decision making. A page of FAQ's is also available.

Contents

Introduction
SFRA Role, Values and Benefits
SFRA Basics - What is it and how is it done
Key to Useful Measurements
SFRA Case Studies
SFRA Support Material and FAQ's
The Doble FRA User Group and Web Discussion Forum

Introduction

We hope this site provides useful information to allow you to:

bullet understanding the role, value and benefits of SFRA in transformer testing.
bullet understanding the Doble M5100 test set and it's operation.

SFRA Role, Value and Benefits

SFRA is an electrical test which gives information about transformer mechanical integrity. When making decisions about transformers, there is a degree of caution as mistakes may be catastrophic and costly. SFRA helps with decision making, and by removing uncertainty, has a value in its own right.

Problems it can pick up include: shorted turns, hoop buckling, axial collapse, clamping structure failure and related problems. Case studies are available for each situation.

There is value in the identification of problems, but there is also great value in being able to say that there is unlikely to be a problem: where SFRA results show no change with a baseline, this is very strong evidence that there has been no significant winding movement and/or distortion within the transformer. This is without the requirement of an internal inspection which entails costly outages, maintenance personnel intrusion and oil handling, all of which may reveal nothing. Testimonials as to the value of SFRA have been collected.

Summary: value/benefit is identifying where a problem exists; however, a null result is very useful in identifying an 'all systems go' situation, particularly after a fault.

SFRA Basics - what is it and how is it done

The Technical Paper gives a good introduction to SFRA overall; in addition we have two documents used for CSE training which look at the basics of SFRA:

bullet Basics 1 looks at responses from test coils in a number of arrangements and the resonances they produce.
bullet Basics 2 looks at test issues: grounds, cables, noise and how to make a good measurement.
bullet An Interpretation Guide is under development.
 

Connections for SFRA tests on different transformer designs are given in a connection guide. this is not exhaustive, but has the bulk of transformer designs.

Key to Useful Measurements

A good measurement is one which can be repeated in the future. This requires that the result be independent of:

bullet test lead arrangement
bullet test set

The M5100 provides good repeatable measurements which may be relied on for decision making.

Case Studies

Cases listed here cover common failures and show the value of SFRA and good repeatable measurements.

Axial collapse - seven years after original SFRA measurements
Hoop buckling of inner winding
Shorted Turn - is very easy to spot with a number of diagnostic tests
Clamping Failure - resulting in changed capacitance of main winding
Bushing failure - transformer shown to be OK
Relocation - confirmation of integrity
Repeatability over time and with different test sets

Back to Top

SFRA Support Material and FAQ's

Short documents are available which include:

Doble's input to standards development, such as our paper to the IEEE Standards development is based on the technical requirements of the measurement and is non-commercial. Contact Doble for the latest revisions.
A list Doble papers available from the Doble Knowledgebase
Typical results for different transformer designs
Transformer purchase specification to include FRA
FAQ's - please add more by sending your Frequently Asked Questions to us at SFRA_UG@doble.com

A results library is available to clients at http://www.doble.com/sfra_data/ which may be accessed via a username and password

The Doble FRA User Group and Web Discussion Forum

The Doble FRA user group meets twice a year to discuss applications, results and experiences.

The Web Discussion Forum is available for discussion of results, procedures etc.

If as a result of using this RSM and Reps Center you have any questions, comments or feedback we would appreciate hearing from you. Please contact the SFRA Product Manager at:

SFRA_UG@doble.com

SFRA Product Manager
Doble Engineering
85 Walnut Street
Watertown
MA 02472
USA

Office phone: ++1 (617) 926 4900
Office fax: ++1 (617) 926 052